⚖️ Section 230 🗣️ First Amendment 🤖 AI Liability

Browse Cases

22 results
Publisher Immunity Trial Court Opinion

Karam v. Meta Platforms, Inc.

District Court, N.D. California · 2025-02-12 · Meta (Facebook)

Issue: Whether Section 230 bars claims against Meta arising from the company's decision to ban or restrict plaintiff's Facebook account and its alleged failure to prevent other users from posting content about plaintiff.

This decision reinforces the broad application of Section 230 immunity to platform account termination and content moderation decisions, extending publisher immunity not only to third-party content but also to the platform's own editorial decisions about which users may access its services. The ruling demonstrates courts' continued willingness to apply Section 230 at the motion to dismiss stage to bar claims challenging fundamental platform curation functions including account access decisions.

View on CourtListener →
Speech Regulation / Platform Autonomy; Compelled Speech / Forced Hosting Appellate Opinion

Students Engaged in Advancing Texas v. Ken Paxton, Attorney General, State of Texas

Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit · 2025-02-11 · Social media platforms (represented by Computer & Communications Industry Association and NetChoice trade associations)

Issue: Whether Texas HB18, a state law regulating social media platforms' content moderation and targeted advertising practices directed at minors, violates the First Amendment and is preempted by Section 230.

This appeal presents a post-Moody test case for state regulation of social media platforms' treatment of minors and targeted advertising practices. The Fifth Circuit's resolution will clarify how Moody's framework for evaluating must-carry and content moderation mandates applies to age-based restrictions and commercial speech regulations, and whether Section 230 preempts state laws targeting platform design features and advertising practices rather than third-party content liability.

View on CourtListener →